Negative interest rates ?

Cyle

Active VIP Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2008
Messages
7,171
Reaction score
4,722
Location
edmonton
Whatever happened to Dad's saying save money for a rainy day and then we get a government that props up all the slobs who never did that. Kinda setting a presedent that saving is overrated when the govt bails everyone out.

I think a lot of it happened simply because they knew how many people had no savings or way to pay their bills and it would be a disaster and collapse the economy. If let's say 30% of the country was totally broke, it's going to trickle down to so many businesses loosing revenue causing more layoffs, etc. I don't like the government stepping in, but you have to blame the broke people, not the government for it.
 

Cdnfireman

Active VIP Member
Joined
Sep 11, 2012
Messages
2,726
Reaction score
9,527
Location
Alberta
Yes and no, a happy medium will make you the most wealth and securely. I can't imagine buying a house, paying it off totally then investing. It's also good debt vs bad. I own 3 rentals all of which have mortgages, big difference between that good debt and buying tons of toys, vehicles, or risky stocks, etc. Unless you have a massive income, it'll take a long time to pay off that house and try to build any real wealth. Sure if you want to retire at 65 and be comfortable, it'll get you there. But many want to do a lot better then that.

Define good debt.....your rentals are “good debt” until they sit vacant because of the economy.....that good debt turns into bad debt in a hurry...and someone with the discipline to hit their mortgage hard won’t be buying a ton of toys etc...they’ll be aware that they can get them on a low interest HELOC once they get the mortgage taken care of. Your philosophy can work well if everything goes your way, but it can also destroy you financially too if things go south. Lots of people that have leveraged one rental against the others have lost their ass.....
 

Cdnfireman

Active VIP Member
Joined
Sep 11, 2012
Messages
2,726
Reaction score
9,527
Location
Alberta
Whatever happened to Dad's saying save money for a rainy day and then we get a government that props up all the slobs who never did that. Kinda setting a presedent that saving is overrated when the govt bails everyone out.

This propping up of people will only be short term....the government will eventually run out of money and have to raise interest rates to attract bond holders. That will start the vicious cycle of borrowing and interest increases....and the interest increases will slaughter the people holding big debt....always has...
 

Frosty19

Active VIP Member
Joined
Jun 20, 2013
Messages
360
Reaction score
594
Location
Saskatchewan
The more I read this thread, the more it basically just sums up no one can really predict the future especially right now. Most people seem to be locking in 5 years on their mortgage (some trying for 10) at the historically low rates
Easy to say what's good and bad after it's already happened. Buying and investing is a risk regardless, theres still "good" risk imo
As long as the ratio of what you bought versus what you owe is a safe amount you should be ok barring any uncontrollable circumstance and you still have a life to live
 
Last edited:

Cyle

Active VIP Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2008
Messages
7,171
Reaction score
4,722
Location
edmonton
Define good debt.....your rentals are “good debt” until they sit vacant because of the economy.....that good debt turns into bad debt in a hurry...and someone with the discipline to hit their mortgage hard won’t be buying a ton of toys etc...they’ll be aware that they can get them on a low interest HELOC once they get the mortgage taken care of. Your philosophy can work well if everything goes your way, but it can also destroy you financially too if things go south. Lots of people that have leveraged one rental against the others have lost their ass.....

Why would they ever be vacant because of the economy? People always need a place to live, and in uncertain economic times more people want to rent rather then buy. Rental rates will go down sure, but there will always be renters for starter homes. In 6 years i've never had one vacant more then a month looking for a tenant, and most tenants stay a long time. If you have rentals, you need to have the funds available to carry them in the event they are vacant for a bit. But if one is vacant more then 2 months, you are asking too much for it. Some people are foolish and let them sit instead of just lowering the price. To me, $100 even $200 a month isn't worth it. Get a decent tenant in there and you're still making money even if not as much. If you own 3 rentals for 25 years and pay them off, that's an extremely good retirement fund all on it's own.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: LID

JayT

Active VIP Member
Joined
May 9, 2010
Messages
2,960
Reaction score
10,913
Location
Parkland county
Why would they ever be vacant because of the economy? People always need a place to live, and in uncertain economic times more people want to rent rather then buy. Rental rates will go down sure, but there will always be renters for starter homes. In 6 years i've never had one vacant more then a month looking for a tenant, and most tenants stay a long time. If you have rentals, you need to have the funds available to carry them in the event they are vacant for a bit. But if one is vacant more then 2 months, you are asking too much for it. Some people are foolish and let them sit instead of just lowering the price. To me, $100 even $200 a month isn't worth it. Get a decent tenant in there and you're still making money even if not as much. If you own 3 rentals for 25 years and pay them off, that's an extremely good retirement fund all on it's own.
So if interest rates go to 20% again where would you be at? Right now they're printing an enormous amount of money and inflation is going to be a problem within the next two years. So I'm just curious if you have a plan for that scenario. I cant imagine you could raise rent enough to cover that kind of interest rate hike. Would you still be able to break even at the end of the day? Obviously people are going to want to rent if interest rates go that high so you wouldn't have a problem with vacancy.
 

Cyle

Active VIP Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2008
Messages
7,171
Reaction score
4,722
Location
edmonton
So if interest rates go to 20% again where would you be at? Right now they're printing an enormous amount of money and inflation is going to be a problem within the next two years. So I'm just curious if you have a plan for that scenario. I cant imagine you could raise rent enough to cover that kind of interest rate hike. Would you still be able to break even at the end of the day? Obviously people are going to want to rent if interest rates go that high so you wouldn't have a problem with vacancy.

If rates go that high, rent prices will follow, and you're right rent demand would skyrocket. There is no way rates could ever get that high, I bet like 5% of the population at most could afford their mortgage at that rate, and probably even less in terms of rent high enough pay for that kind of mortgage. If rates did somehow go that high, i'd just sell 1 rental that was nearest or at renewal maybe, and pay off all the other mortgages as they came up to renewal if rates were still insane. So other then maybe selling 1 at a low price, having cheap money while rent skyrockets would be good profit for a bit as all my renewals are spread out.
 

Frosty19

Active VIP Member
Joined
Jun 20, 2013
Messages
360
Reaction score
594
Location
Saskatchewan
So if interest rates go to 20% again where would you be at? Right now they're printing an enormous amount of money and inflation is going to be a problem within the next two years. So I'm just curious if you have a plan for that scenario. I cant imagine you could raise rent enough to cover that kind of interest rate hike. Would you still be able to break even at the end of the day? Obviously people are going to want to rent if interest rates go that high so you wouldn't have a problem with vacancy.

I wouldnt be worried about a rental property if rates went up 18% of where they are now in the course of even 10 years. The entire economy would come into question and the "dollar" would hold no true value in society if it was that volatile IMO
 
Last edited:

JayT

Active VIP Member
Joined
May 9, 2010
Messages
2,960
Reaction score
10,913
Location
Parkland county
I wouldnt be worried about a rental property if rates went up 18% of where they are now in the course of even 10 years. The entire economy would come into question and the "dollar" would hold no true value in society if it was that volatile IMO
So basically what you're saying is everybody is up schitt creek. In that scenario what would be the best position to be in? I feel like having no debt and money in the Bank to take advantage of interest rates would be the best-case scenario. And maybe some precious metals, something that holds intrinsic value.
 

JayT

Active VIP Member
Joined
May 9, 2010
Messages
2,960
Reaction score
10,913
Location
Parkland county
If rates go that high, rent prices will follow, and you're right rent demand would skyrocket. There is no way rates could ever get that high, I bet like 5% of the population at most could afford their mortgage at that rate, and probably even less in terms of rent high enough pay for that kind of mortgage. If rates did somehow go that high, i'd just sell 1 rental that was nearest or at renewal maybe, and pay off all the other mortgages as they came up to renewal if rates were still insane. So other then maybe selling 1 at a low price, having cheap money while rent skyrockets would be good profit for a bit as all my renewals are spread out.
Would you actually be able to sell a property? There would not be a lot of people buying at that point, and there would be a lot of people selling their rental properties all at the same time. Prices of property would drop so fast it would make your head spin. I am honestly curious about how to handle that scenario the best because I feel like this is coming in our near future. It took Venezuela 10 years to go from an economic Powerhouse to a socialist sh°thole, Trudeau has been in power for 5. I truly hope it doesn't happen but I think we are headed for some seriously bad times
 

Pedaling pete

Active VIP Member
Joined
Sep 23, 2015
Messages
1,622
Reaction score
3,648
Location
dark side of the moon
Having off shore bank accounts and having some gold bars in a vault in Switzerland never hurt. But most y'all are just going to have to tough it out lol
 

Pedaling pete

Active VIP Member
Joined
Sep 23, 2015
Messages
1,622
Reaction score
3,648
Location
dark side of the moon
Having off shore bank accounts and having some gold bars in a vault in Switzerland never hurt. But most y'all are just going to have to tough it out lol

I dont think you have to worry about 20% rates any time soon . No country would be able to afford that. At some point this system will collapse and we'll come up with a new one. Just a matter of when.
 
Last edited:

Bnorth

Active VIP Member
Joined
Dec 18, 2010
Messages
10,547
Reaction score
20,134
Location
Salmon Arm
Bunch of different viewpoints in here but the fact that everyone is even talking about it and managing their debt in some form is proof you're on the right track.
 

Bogger

Bogger of the GBCA
Joined
Feb 21, 2007
Messages
24,413
Reaction score
18,488
Location
Down by the Bay
I'm envious of Cycles position, to be holding multiple rentals even with partial debt and an uncertain economic future is a decent place to be. If we were to get to the point where we are looking at double digit interest rates a lot of folks would be unable to maintain thier principal residence let lone worry about additional properties, in that scenario Cyle would end up less profitable but I doubt he'd end up taking a loss, maybe on one property but that would enable him to maintain and leverage the other two.

I want to be in the "debt-free" position ASAP, but that's my preference does not mean that Cyle's logic is flawed, it's just personal choice. If interest rates took off into double digit territory I'd be able to manage that comfortably at the end of my most current mortgage, I will owe less than 1/4 of my current property value and if need be could enter into an interest only type structure until rates settled down. I'm not relying on the sale of my property to finance my retirement, the wife and I have a decent savings and investment plan which we will ramp up when the house is paid off and she will collect a very livable pension. I also plan to continue part time consultant work after I retire from the rat race..... I wish I had of invested in properties back in the late 90's & early 2000's instead of toys & booze (In 1999 a nice 1400 sq/ft house in Edmonton could be had for $110K) but I didn't so now I'm planning to do what is most comfortable for me given the current times. They are not making anymore lakes in Alberta so I want my property paid off with zero liens
 

rsaruk

Active VIP Member
Joined
Jul 28, 2009
Messages
357
Reaction score
520
Location
Stony Plain
My bank just offered me 1.74 for 4 years or 1.9 for 5. What do the experts think would be the better one. Worried if rates go up then I don't get that last year at a lower rate.
Just a follow up, I was able to negotiate a bit more off and ended up signing for 1.8 locked in for 5 years.
 

Bnorth

Active VIP Member
Joined
Dec 18, 2010
Messages
10,547
Reaction score
20,134
Location
Salmon Arm
I signed my renewal last week. 1.79 for a fixed 5er. I switched from a monoline lender to a bank so I could have the option of securing a line of credit against up to 80% of my equity. We will only do this if we pickup another property and need more down payment. Either a bigger property for us or a rental.
 

Frosty19

Active VIP Member
Joined
Jun 20, 2013
Messages
360
Reaction score
594
Location
Saskatchewan
Saw an article title stating today certain banks were offering 0.99% 5 year variable rate mortgages and that was a first in Canadian history.
 
Top Bottom