Who would you rather have on your team?

[Verti-Kyle]

Dionne Phaneuf or Sheldon Souray?
Jerome Iginla or Ales Hemsky?
Mikka Kipersof or Dwayne Roloson?
Todd Bertuzzi or Dustin Penner?
Robin Regher or Steve Staios?
Sam Gagne or Mike Camalleri?
Fernando Pisani or Craig Conroy?

Curious to see the value that others put on these players. And yes I anticipate some jokers will say they would take a bag of pucks over any of the Flames/Oilers players. Put your team bias aside and who would you choose? Add some others to the list as well.
ie. Shawn Horcoff or ?

 

[scrfce]

Dionne Phaneuf or Sheldon Souray?
Jerome Iginla or Ales Hemsky?
Mikka Kipersof or Dwayne Roloson?
Todd Bertuzzi or Dustin Penner?
Robin Regher or Steve Staios?
Sam Gagne or Mike Camalleri?
Fernando Pisani or Craig Conroy?

Curious to see the value that others put on these players. And yes I anticipate some jokers will say they would take a bag of pucks over any of the Flames/Oilers players. Put your team bias aside and who would you choose? Add some others to the list as well.
ie. Shawn Horcoff or ?

i am not a fan of either team but here r my picks
iggy
kipper
big bert
regher
camalleri
conroy

oil suck!!!!:d

 

[blastoff]

Dionne Phaneuf or Sheldon Souray?
Jerome Iginla or Ales Hemsky?
Mikka Kipersof or Dwayne Roloson?
Todd Bertuzzi or Dustin Penner?
Robin Regher or Steve Staios?
Sam Gagne or Mike Camalleri?
Fernando Pisani or Craig Conroy?

Iggy
Rollie
Bertuzi
Regher
Gange
Souray
Mact cause he is toast I think then he would still get paid

 

[Verti-Kyle]

i am not a fan of either team but here r my picks
iggy
kipper
big bert
regher
camalleri
conroy

oil suck!!!!:d

Ya, I can't deny that this year they royaly $hit the bed.
Don't forget that your precious little Iggy is a proud born and raised Edmontonian. (well..,St.Albert but close enough).
This year was just a testing ground for our surplus of young talent. Go ahead Flamers enjoy your first round and we'll see ya on the course soon.
Next year, heres what the Oil need to do
1. Dump Mac T...if they don't, the fans will probably lynch him and then he's no good to anybody.
2. Trade a couple of skill guys ie.Nilsson, O'sullivan (or Cogliano) for a big power forward who will actually get his nose dirty. (Bertuzzi like player that does not get injured as much)
3. Sign Roli for 1 more season. Don't beat him like a rented mule with 35 consecutive starts but why not...who else you want?
The question is, who should coach the Oilers next year?

 

[snotterite]

Dionne Phaneuf or Sheldon Souray?
Jerome Iginla or Ales Hemsky?
Mikka Kipersof or Dwayne Roloson?
Todd Bertuzzi or Dustin Penner?
Robin Regher or Steve Staios?
Sam Gagne or Mike Camalleri?
Fernando Pisani or Craig Conroy?

Curious to see the value that others put on these players. And yes I anticipate some jokers will say they would take a bag of pucks over any of the Flames/Oilers players. Put your team bias aside and who would you choose? Add some others to the list as well.
ie. Shawn Horcoff or ?

I'll take all the Flames except DP. Oilers can have him free of charge.